Holle

Holle vs. Similac: A Comprehensive Ingredient Comparison

JuneReviewed by the OLS parent-proofing process — reputable sources & pediatric insights
Fact Checked
Holle vs. Similac: A Comprehensive Ingredient Comparison

 

46 hours of research 4 minute read

" Holle baby formulas are known for their organic and biodynamic ingredients, while Similac provides a range of options to meet various nutritional needs. "
Holle vs. Similac: A Comprehensive Ingredient Comparison

When choosing the best baby formula for your little one, two prominent names often come up: Holle formula and the Similac formula. Both brands are well-regarded and have a loyal following among parents. In this blog, we will delve into the similarities and differences between these two brands, focusing on their ingredients, certifications, and available varieties. This comprehensive guide will help you make an informed decision about which formula is best suited for your baby’s needs.

Similarities Between Holle and Similac

Organic Ingredients Yes Yes (for some products)
GMO-Free Yes Yes (for some products)
DHA and ARA Yes Yes
Lactose-Based Yes Yes
Prebiotics and Probiotics Yes (in some products) Yes (in some products)
Multiple Stages Available Yes No
Available in Goat Milk Yes No
Iron-Fortified Yes Yes

Both the Holle formula and Similac formula share several key features that make them attractive options for parents. They both use high-quality ingredients, avoid GMOs, and provide essential nutrients like DHA and ARA for brain development. Additionally, they offer a range of products tailored to different stages of infant growth.

Origin and Standards of Holle and Similac

Holle Baby Formula originates from Switzerland and Germany, where it has been produced for over 85 years. Holle is renowned for its strict adherence to organic farming standards and biodynamic agricultural practices. Their dedication to excellence guarantees that their formulas have an absence of genetically engineered organisms, harmful pesticides, and chemical fertilizers.

On the other hand, Similac Baby Formula is produced by Abbott Laboratories, a US-based company with a long history of providing infant nutrition products. Similac formulas are developed using cutting-edge science and are designed to meet the nutritional needs of infants and toddlers. While not all Similac products are organic, the brand offers several non-GMO options.

Certifications for Both Holle and Similac

Demeter International Yes No
EU Organic Certification Yes No
Bioland Yes No
KRAV Yes No
USDA Organic Certification No Yes (for some products)
Non-GMO Project Verified Yes Yes (for some products)
FDA Approval Yes Yes

Holle Reputation

Strict organic rules in the European Union (EU) have led to Holle's reputation for using superior organic components in their goods. For more than 80 years, parents who appreciate organic and all-natural products have been loyal customers of the brand.

Certifications by Holle

  • Demeter International for biodynamic farming methods
  • EU Organic Certification
  • Bioland
  • KRAV

Similac Reputation

Since it has been in existence for more than 90 years, Similac infant formula is a reputable and well-known brand. They are devoted to giving babies nutritious food and are a pioneer in the infant formula sector. Abbott Laboratories is committed to meeting newborns' and kids' nutritional needs, and one of their products is Similac.

They have multiple certifications, such as the Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval and the National Parenting Center Seal of Approval. Given the endorsement of medical professionals including pediatricians and neonatologists, parents often select Similac.

Ingredients Comparison Between Holle and Similac

Holle Ingredients

  • Organic lactose
  • Organic vegetable oils (palm, rapeseed, sunflower)
  • Demeter milk
  • Organic maltodextrin
  • Organic whey powder
  • Prebiotics (GOS)
  • DHA and ARA
  • Vitamins and minerals

Similac Ingredients

  • Nonfat milk
  • Lactose
  • Vegetable oils (palm olein, soy, coconut, high oleic safflower)
  • Whey protein concentrate
  • Prebiotics (FOS)
  • DHA and ARA
  • Vitamins and minerals
  • Nucleotides

Holle vs Similac Ingredients (Comparison Chart)

HOLLE BIO ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌
HOLLE A2 ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌
HOLLE GOAT ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌
SIMILAC PURE BLISS ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌ ✅ ✅ ❌
SIMILAC 360 TOTAL CARE ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌ ✅ ✅ ✅
SIMILAC PRO-TOTAL COMFORT ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ✅ ✅ ✅
SIMILAC ALIMENTUM ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌
SIMILAC TOTAL COMFORT ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ✅ ✅ ❌
SIMILAC ADVANCE ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ❌ ✅ ✅ ❌
SIMILAC SENSITIVE ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌
SIMILAC NEOSURE ❌ ✅ ✅ ❌ ❌ ✅ ❌ ❌

Holle Goat Milk Formula and Holle Goat Milk Formula Stage 1 use organic goat milk as their primary ingredient, making them an excellent choice for babies with cow’s milk sensitivities. The use of maltodextrin in Holle formulas provides a gentle source of carbohydrates.

Similac Sensitive Formula and Similac Advance Formula are designed to cater to various dietary needs and sensitivities. Similac uses a combination of nonfat milk and whey protein concentrate, along with vegetable oils, to provide balanced nutrition.

Similarities and Differences

Similarities

  • Both brands offer a range of formulas for different stages of infant development.
  • They both include essential fatty acids (DHA and ARA) for brain and eye development.
  • Lactose serves as the main source of carbohydrates in both.

Differences

  • Holle Bio Formula uses biodynamic milk, while Similac Total Comfort Formula uses nonfat milk and whey protein.
  • Holle formulas are certified by the EU Organic and Demeter, while Similac offers USDA Organic options.
  • Holle Goat Milk Formula is available for infants with cow’s milk sensitivities, whereas Similac does not offer a goat milk variant.

Key Differences Between Holle and Similac

Brand Reputation Organic ingredients for over 80 years Well-known and reputable for over 90 years
Certifications Demeter International, EU organic, Bioland, KRAV National Parenting Center, Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval
Nutritional Value Complete, in stages Complete, from 0-12 months
Proteins Organic Skimmed Milk Non-Organic Milk. It has a Soy formula and a Hydrolyzed formula.
Carbohydrates Organic lactose and maltodextrin (only some formulas) Lactose and corn syrup solids. Comfort uses maltodextrin. Most formulas add sugar
Fats and Oils Organic vegetable oils All formulas contain non-organic soy oil. Similac does not use palm olein like Enfamil.
Probiotics and Prebiotics No probiotics or prebiotics Most formulas contain GOS or FOS
Cost and Availability Varies per retailer. Exclusively sold online in the US Widely available in stores and online

Stages of Holle Formulas

Holle Goat Milk Formula Stages

Holle Goat Milk Formula comes in five stages. Stage PRE and Stage 4 are only available in the regular Holle Goat formula, whereas both Holle Goat formula versions (Dutch and regular goat) have Stages 1-3:

Holle Cow Milk Formula

The ingredients of Holle cow milk formula are renowned for being clean and simple. The most widely used and accessible formula is cow milk formula, which is produced by Holle in two varieties. Both the Holle A2 formula and the normal Holle cow milk formula are Demeter certified, which means that 99 percent of the ingredients are organic and the remaining 1 percent are non-organic substances such as vital vitamins and minerals that are necessary for a baby's healthy growth and development. The cows are also guaranteed plenty of room to move about and graze freely in biodynamic pastures thanks to the Demeter-certified formula.

Holle Bio Formula

The most popular variety of Holle cow milk infant formula is called Holle Bio Formula, and it is well known for having a simple and clean ingredient list. Holle cow formula contains no GMOs, no soy, no sugar, and no corn syrup. Holle Bio infant formula Stage 1 and Stage PRE do not contain starch, whereas toddler formulas Stage 2-4 do contain organic starch which will fill your baby’s tummy and make them feel fuller for longer. Holle cow formulas contain DHA Omega-3 and Omega-6 sourced from ethically sourced fish oil. Lactose is the primary carbohydrate in Holle Bio formulas.

Holle Bio Formula comes in five stages:

Holle A2 Formula

Holle A2 formula is made of cow milk from cows that contain the A2 beta-casein protein type. What this means is that Holle A2 formula is easier to digest than regular cow milk baby formula, since A2 milk has shorter fatty acid chains than cow milk without the A2 protein. Because Holle A2 baby formula is simpler to digest, parents of babies with cow milk sensitivity who still want to use cow milk formula occasionally switch from ordinary cow milk baby formula to it. Holle A2 is a lactose-based formula free of sugar, corn syrup, soy, and genetically modified organisms. While Holle A2 Stage 2 and Stage 3 contain organic starch, Holle A2 Stage 1 does not contain any starch. To make a baby feel fuller, small amounts of organic maltodextrin are added to all three stages of the Holle A2 formula.

Holle A2 formula comes in three stages:

Top Formulas of Holle and Similac and Where to Buy

Holle Formulas

  1. Holle Bio Formula
  2. Holle Goat Milk Formula
  3. Holle Dutch Goat

Looking to buy Holle organic formula? Organic Life Start offers an easy-to-use online platform that enhances affordability and accessibility. This platform ensures a smooth shopping experience with discounts and subscription options. These features help parents save on their favorite Holle formulas and ensure a reliable supply for their baby's nutrition. Organic Life Start prioritizes convenience and value, making it a top choice for parents who want premium organic baby formula delivered straight to their door.

Holle Discount Details:

  • Save up to 15% on the largest pack size.
  • Get an extra 5% off with recurring subscriptions.

Top Similac Baby Formulas

  1. Similac Advance Formula
  2. Similac Sensitive Formula
  3. Similac Neosure Formula
  4. Similac Total Comfort Formula
  5. Similac 360 Total Care Infant Formula
  6. Similac Toddler Formula

What Sets Holle Apart from Similac?

While this blog focuses on Holle and Similac, it’s worth noting what sets Holle apart from Similac. Holle’s commitment to biodynamic farming, strict organic certifications, and the availability of goat milk formulas distinguish it from other brands. Similac offers USDA Organic-certified products and advanced nutritional formulations, but Holle's Demeter certification and European origins provide a different level of quality assurance and farming practices.

Both Holle formula and Similac formula provide excellent options for infant nutrition, each with its unique strengths. Understanding the ingredients, certifications, and available varieties can help you choose the best formula for your baby’s specific needs.

Most Popular Holle Baby Formulas

  1. Holle Bio Formula
  2. Holle Goat Milk Formula
  3. Holle Dutch Goat
FAQ: Holle vs Similac
What is the main difference between Holle and Similac?
Holle is a European brand made with organic, Demeter biodynamic milk and EU organic ingredients, and it comes in age-based stages. Similac is a US brand by Abbott with mostly conventional ingredients, a few USDA organic options, and a wider range of specialty formulas, including hydrolyzed and soy-based options.
Does Similac contain corn syrup?
Some Similac formulas do. Similac Sensitive and NeoSure use corn syrup solids as a carbohydrate source, while formulas like Similac Advance and Similac 360 Total Care are lactose-based. Check the ingredient list of the specific product. Holle formulas use lactose as their main carbohydrate and contain no corn syrup.
Is Holle better than Similac?
Both are nutritionally complete. Parents often choose Holle for its organic and biodynamic ingredients and lactose-based recipes without corn syrup or soy. Similac may suit families who need a widely available formula or a specialty product, such as a hypoallergenic formula for a diagnosed milk allergy.
Does Holle make a hypoallergenic formula?
No. Holle doesn't currently offer a hydrolyzed formula for babies with cow's milk protein allergy (CMPA). Similac Alimentum is an extensively hydrolyzed formula used for CMPA. Browse our hypoallergenic formulas and talk to your pediatrician if your baby may have a milk allergy.
Does Holle have a goat milk formula?
Yes. Holle offers Holle Goat and Holle Goat Dutch, which some babies with mild cow milk sensitivity find easier to digest. Similac doesn't offer a goat milk formula. Goat milk formulas are not suitable for babies with a diagnosed cow's milk protein allergy.
Does Holle contain palm oil or fish oil?
Holle formulas use a blend of organic vegetable oils, and their DHA comes from fish oil. Since recipes can differ between Holle lines, check the ingredient list of the specific product if you want to avoid palm oil. Similac doesn't use palm olein oil.
How do I switch from Similac to Holle?
Most babies can switch gradually over about 5 days by mixing more of the new formula each day. Prepare each formula separately according to its own instructions, because the scoop-to-water ratio is different: Similac typically uses one scoop per 2 oz (60 ml) of water, while Holle uses one scoop per 1 oz (30 ml). Read our guide on how to switch your baby's formula.

Organic Life Start is committed to providing accurate, reliable, and trustworthy information to parents and caregivers. We carefully choose credible sources and follow a meticulous fact-checking process to uphold the highest standards in infant nutrition and parenting advice. To learn more about our dedication to accuracy, please explore our editorial guidelines.

Link To Sources

Keep Reading

All guides

67 comments

  • -

    This changed how I look at formula comparisons. I used to focus mainly on the brand and price, but now I pay more attention to the actual ingredients, protein sources, and carbohydrate blends. Two formulas can both meet infant nutrition requirements while still having quite different ingredient lists.

  • -

    I’ve always been familiar with Similac, but now I’m curious about trying Holle after learning more about their ingredient differences. Has anyone switched from Similac to Holle, and what was your experience?

  • -

    Similac is what I see most often at our local stores, so I never paid much attention to Holle until a friend mentioned it. I was curious how their ingredients compared, and this answered a few questions I had.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Back to European Formula Guides