Total: $0.00
Baby can't wait?
(exclusive offer)
Alternatives to Kendamil Goat - Finding the Right Formula for Your Baby
Update (July 2026): Kendamil Goat is now back in stock at OLS. If it's available and your baby is happy on it - no need to switch. This guide is for parents who need alternatives due to availability gaps, price concerns, or because their baby didn't tolerate Kendamil Goat well.
Quick Match: What You Like About Kendamil Goat → Best Alternative
Like the whole milk + MFGM?
→ Nannycare ($36.50/900g) - also whole goat milk with natural MFGM. NZ sourced.
Want organic certification?
→ HiPP Goat ($36.85/800g) or Holle Goat ($28.30/400g) - both EU Organic certified.
Want the cheapest goat option?
→ Holle Goat ($28.30/400g) - Demeter-level farming standards at the lowest price.
Need FDA-registered + US retail?
→ Kabrita ($53.00/800g) - available at Target + Amazon. Beta-palmitate included.
All 5 Goat Milk Formulas Compared
Every goat milk formula uses A2 beta-casein protein and forms softer curds than cow milk. The differences are in milk base (whole vs skim), organic certification, DHA source, and price:
| Feature | Kendamil Goat | HiPP Goat | Holle Goat | Nannycare | Kabrita |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price (Stage 1) | $60.60 | $36.85 | $28.30 ✓ | $36.50 | $53.00 |
| Size | 800g | 800g | 400g | 900g ✓ | 800g |
| Price/100g | $7.58 | $4.61 | $7.08 | $4.06 ✓ | $6.63 |
| Milk base | Whole goat (MFGM) ✓ | Skim goat | Skim goat | Whole goat ✓ | Skim goat |
| Organic | No | EU Organic ✓ | EU Organic ✓ | No | No |
| DHA source | Algae ✓ | Fish oil | Algae ✓ | Fish oil | Fish oil |
| Palm oil | Free ✓ | Free ✓ | Free ✓ | Free ✓ | Free ✓ |
| Prebiotics | GOS | GOS | None | GOS | GOS |
| Beta-palmitate | No | No | No | No | Yes ✓ |
| Starch (Stage 1) | None ✓ | None ✓ | None ✓ | None ✓ | None ✓ |
| Stages available | 1, 2, 3 | 1, 2, 3 | PRE, 1, 2, 3, 4 | 1, 2, 3 | 1, 2, 3 |
| FDA registered | Yes ✓ | No | No | No | Yes ✓ |
| OLS status | In Stock ✓ | In Stock ✓ | In Stock ✓ | In Stock ✓ | Waitlist ⏳ |
Which Alternative Matches Your Priority?
| What you like about Kendamil Goat | Best alternative | Why it matches |
|---|---|---|
| Whole milk with MFGM | Nannycare | Also uses whole goat milk (not skim + oils). Natural MFGM present. $36.50/900g - best per-100g value. |
| Algae DHA (no fish smell) | Holle Goat | Uses algae-derived DHA - vegetarian, no fishy odor. Also palm oil-free. $28.30/400g. |
| No palm oil | Any of the 4 | All 5 goat formulas on this list are palm oil-free. |
| EU Organic certification | HiPP Goat or Holle Goat | Both EU Organic. Kendamil Goat is not organic. HiPP adds GOS prebiotics. |
| Lowest price overall | Holle Goat | $28.30/400g. Even cheaper with multi-pack: ~$27.35/box. |
| Best per-100g value | Nannycare | $4.06/100g in 900g cans. Kendamil is $7.58/100g - nearly double. |
| FDA-registered for US retail | Kabrita | FDA-registered like Kendamil. Available at Target + Amazon. Adds beta-palmitate. |
| Widest stage range (including PRE) | Holle Goat | Only goat formula with PRE stage (starch-free, thinnest flow for combo feeding). |
💡 Our recommendation: If Kendamil Goat is available and your baby likes it, stay on it. If switching: HiPP Goat is the best all-rounder alternative (organic, prebiotics, $36.85). Holle Goat is the budget choice ($28.30). Nannycare is the closest match to Kendamil's whole-milk philosophy.
How to Switch Goat Formulas Safely
Switching between goat formulas is easier than switching from cow to goat - the A2 protein structure is similar across all goat brands. Still, transition gradually:
- Days 1-2: 75% Kendamil Goat + 25% new formula
- Days 3-4: 50% / 50%
- Days 5-6: 25% Kendamil + 75% new formula
- Day 7+: 100% new formula
Watch for: changes in stool consistency (normal during transition), increased gas (usually resolves by day 5), and feeding refusal (try warming the new formula slightly - goat formulas taste slightly different between brands).
⚠️ Important: Goat milk formula is for mild cow milk sensitivity - not for diagnosed CMPA. Goat proteins cross-react with cow milk in 90%+ of allergy cases. If your baby has eczema, blood in stool, or respiratory symptoms, consult your pediatrician about hypoallergenic formula instead.
Kendamil Goat Alternatives - FAQ
What formula is most similar to Kendamil Goat?
Nannycare is the closest match - both use whole goat milk (not skim + oils), so both naturally contain MFGM. Nannycare costs $36.50/900g vs Kendamil's $60.60/800g - significantly cheaper. The main difference: Nannycare uses fish oil for DHA while Kendamil uses algae.
Which goat formula is cheapest?
Holle Goat at $28.30/400g is the lowest absolute price. For best per-100g value, Nannycare at $4.06/100g (900g cans) beats everyone including Holle ($7.08/100g). With multi-pack + subscription discounts, monthly cost can drop to ~$110-130.
Is HiPP Goat better than Kendamil Goat?
Different strengths. HiPP Goat ($36.85) is EU Organic certified and cheaper. Kendamil Goat ($60.60) uses whole goat milk with MFGM and algae DHA (vegetarian, no fish smell). HiPP uses skim goat milk + oils and fish-based DHA. If organic matters → HiPP. If whole milk/MFGM matters → Kendamil or Nannycare.
Can I switch from Kendamil Goat to Holle Goat?
Yes - both use A2 goat protein, so the switch is smooth. Transition over 5-7 days (gradual mixing). Note: Holle comes in 400g boxes (not 800g cans), so you'll open more packages per month. Holle adds organic starch from Stage 2 while Kendamil stays starch-free at all stages.
Is Kabrita a good alternative to Kendamil Goat?
Kabrita ($53.00/800g) is FDA-registered like Kendamil and adds beta-palmitate (structured fat for softer stools). Downsides: not organic, uses skim goat milk (no MFGM), and currently on waitlist at OLS. If available: good for parents who want FDA-registered + US retail accessibility. If not available: HiPP Goat is the better in-stock option.
Why is Kendamil Goat so expensive compared to alternatives?
Kendamil Goat ($60.60/800g) costs more because it uses whole goat milk (more expensive to source than skim), algae DHA (costlier than fish oil), and maintains FDA registration for US retail. Holle Goat at $28.30 is less than half the price but uses skim milk and smaller 400g boxes. For equivalent 800g size: HiPP Goat ($36.85) or Nannycare ($36.50/900g) are the best value.
Do any goat formulas have a PRE stage?
Only Holle Goat PRE ($28.30/400g). It's starch-free with the thinnest consistency - closest to breast milk flow, ideal for combo feeding in the first weeks. Kendamil, HiPP, Nannycare, and Kabrita all start at Stage 1.
Are goat formulas safe for CMPA babies?
No. All goat milk formulas - including Kendamil, HiPP, Holle, Nannycare, and Kabrita - contain goat milk protein that cross-reacts with cow milk protein in over 90% of CMPA cases. Goat formula is for mild sensitivity (gas, fussiness), not diagnosed allergy. For CMPA: HiPP HA (partially hydrolyzed) or Aptamil Pepti (extensively hydrolyzed).
51 comments
Researched & Written
By: Isa
Happy mom of 1. Built her career in the medical equipment industry, and later on converted her passion to serving babies. Organic Life Start customer service since 2022.
Recent Post
Marie Villagomez -
One tip that helped us during formula shortages was keeping a list of a few suitable alternatives approved by our pediatrician. It made stressful situations much easier because we already knew what options to look for if our usual formula wasn’t available.
Amy Dowell -
As great as Kendamil UK Goat is, YOU ABSOLUTELY NEED A BACKUP FORMULA. I’ve experienced a shortage before, and it’s not a great experience.
Demetria Kaminski -
Holle Goat Dutch is the closest to Kendamil Goat! Test it and stock it. You never know!